ESS Settlement Services

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Founders
    • Staff and Affiliates
  • Our Services
    • Structured Settlement Design & Planning
      • In Depth Look At Structures/FAQ
      • Complete Document Preparation & Review
      • Mediation Attendance
    • Life Care Plan & Financial & Economic Needs Analysis
      • Pre and Post Verdict 50(a) & 50(b) Periodic Judgment Analysis
    • Attorney Fee Deferment
    • Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) Analysis & Future Allocation Apportionment
    • Lien Resolution Services
    • Benefits Coordination & Planning Team
      • Medicare, Medicaid & Healthcare Compliance
    • Trust Advisement & Services
    • QSF Services
  • Our Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
    • Request a Proposal

How Dennis Rodman and Confidentiality Clauses may Affect Your Legal Settlement

December 2, 2014 by Randy Levine Leave a Comment

Amos v RodmanThere’s something we’re seeing more and more of here at ESS Settlement Services. It’s subtle, quiet and often sneaks in at the last minute, when all but the sharpest sets of eyes are no longer paying attention. It’s something we think more lawyers should know more about and be wary of: one-sided confidentiality clauses.

It’s no secret that a large percentage of settlements have a confidentiality clause thrown in at some point. This is to ensure that both parties keep the contents of the document private and it’s often important to many clients. The problem arises when only one side is subject to confidentiality and that problem is taxes.

Take the now famous Amos case, for instance, where prominent Chicago Bulls basketball player Dennis Rodman chased a ball out of bounds and fell onto a group of photographers. As Rodman, who was known for erratic behavior, disentangled himself from the throng he kicked photographer Eugene Amos in the groin.

Amos alleged that the kick was intentional and lawyered up, seeking damages for his injuries. Rodman’s attorney contacted him shortly after and the parties agreed to a $200,000 settlement, before a lawsuit was filed. The settlement imposed an obligation on Amos to keep the terms confidential.

Settlements for physical injuries or illnesses are ordinarily tax free, so Amos excluded the full $200,000 from his taxes. However, the IRS audited him and declared that only a nominal amount was tax-free because his injuries were minor and the bulk of the amount was simply to keep the settlement confidential and prevent Amos from defaming or disparaging Rodman. Ultimately, the court ruled that 60 percent was exempt, while 40 percent of the settlement was taxable.

Though the Amos case is unique, it clearly illustrates the dangers of one-sided confidentiality clauses in personal injury cases. In standard settlement agreements, confidentiality is mutual because one party exchanges their silence for the other party’s, not for monetary compensation. In other words, mutual confidentiality dampens the taxable amount because the Supreme Court has ruled that typical personal injury settlements are tax-exempt.

We see cases with this issue all the time and we’d like for lawyers to watch out for one-sided confidentiality clauses and not let them get thrown in at the last minute. In addition to non-mutual confidentiality, lawyers should be concerned about agreements that explicitly state that a portion of the money is just for confidentiality, settlements that require the plaintiff pay liquidated damages for breaching the confidentiality, or if the plaintiff agrees not to assist with criminal prosecution.

While all of these concerns were present in the Amos case, typical personal injury settlements are far simpler and it’s easy to keep them tax exempt, as long as lawyers are watching out for their clients and don’t let the other party sneak any nefarious clauses in at the eleventh hour.

Are you aware of other examples of confidentially clauses affecting a settlement? Please share your thoughts with us by commenting below

Related Posts

  • Knowing When to Say No and When to Say Yes in Settlement Negotiations
  • Understanding the Real Value of a Structured Settlement
  • Tis the Season (for settling lawsuits)
  • How structured settlements can help victims of the Amtrak derailment
  • Why It’s Important to Push Back if an Insurance Company Pushes You

Filed Under: structured settlements Tagged With: Amos v Rodman, confidentiality clause, Dennis Rodman, tax on settlements

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • ABLE Accounts: providing a better life experience for New York’s disabled residents
  • Bringing Your Client to Mediation: the pros and cons considered
  • How To Identify Which Cases Are Ripe For Mediation
  • The CMS Recovery Portal: helping put money in your pocket faster
  • Getting the Most of Out of Your Next Mediation

Search

Tag Cloud

ABLE ACT 2014 Affordable Care Act Amos v Rodman annuity chronic condition confidentiality clause Dennis Rodman Erisa financial planning Health care insurance adjustors IRS law lien resolution Life Care Plan Life Insurance Benefits litigation mediation mediations mediator Medicaid Medical Law Medicare Medicare Liens Medicare Secondary Payer Act Medicare Set Aside medicare set asides MSA MSP notice of hardship conversion Obama Care personal injury law plaintiff plaintiffs private letter ruling settlements Special Needs Trust structured settlements tax free tax free annuity tax free income tax on settlements trial-ready Wrongful Death Wurtz v The Rawlings Company

Our Mission

As a settlement consulting company owned and run by practicing trial attorneys, ESS brings you true plaintiff-based settlement consultants that are dedicated to serving the plaintiff’s bar and remaining on the cutting edge of settlement planning.

Follow Us Online

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Our latest posts

  • ABLE Accounts: providing a better life experience for New York’s disabled residents
  • Bringing Your Client to Mediation: the pros and cons considered
  • How To Identify Which Cases Are Ripe For Mediation
  • The CMS Recovery Portal: helping put money in your pocket faster
  • Getting the Most of Out of Your Next Mediation

Connect With Us

ESS Settlement Services

P: 844-ESS-1212
F: 866-977-1201
E: info@esqsettlements.com
©2015 ESS Settlements Services, LLC - All Rights Reserved

Structured Settlements provided by Sage Settlement Consulting