ESS Settlement Services

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Founders
    • Staff and Affiliates
  • Our Services
    • Structured Settlement Design & Planning
      • In Depth Look At Structures/FAQ
      • Complete Document Preparation & Review
      • Mediation Attendance
    • Life Care Plan & Financial & Economic Needs Analysis
      • Pre and Post Verdict 50(a) & 50(b) Periodic Judgment Analysis
    • Attorney Fee Deferment
    • Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) Analysis & Future Allocation Apportionment
    • Lien Resolution Services
    • Benefits Coordination & Planning Team
      • Medicare, Medicaid & Healthcare Compliance
    • Trust Advisement & Services
    • QSF Services
  • Our Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
    • Request a Proposal

Go Take a Hike Rawlings!

September 10, 2014 by Randy Levine Leave a Comment

erisa liensDealing with Medicare, Medicaid and with ERISA plans can be extremely frustrating for personal injury attorneys.  Lawyers that perform services pursuant to a retainer agreement on a contingency basis are forced to spend many months in the post settlement stages fighting liens that generate no revenue to the firm.  Some lawyers and firms choose to outsource these problems to lien counsel experts,  however in many instances a lawyer is tempted to tell the collection companies like Rawlings to “Take a Hike” on their ERISA lien. The good news is that now NY lawyers can do that when it comes to fully funded ERISA liens!

On July 31, 2014, The U.S. Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit issued a decision reversing the Eastern District Court in Wurtz v. The Rawlings Company, that states that New York General Obligation Law 5-335 shall not be pre-empted by the Federal ERISA statute.  So as a result, lawyer no longer need to fight with collection companies when it comes to  Fully Funded ERISA Plans.

New York State’s GOL 5-335 states that a personal injury settlement presumptively “does not include any compensation for the cost of health care services” or other losses that “are obligated to be paid or reimbursed by a benefit provider/insurer” and that benefit providers/insurers have “no right of subrogation or reimbursement against any such settling party”.

The Federal ERISA statute’s expressly preempts any state law “that relate(s) to any employee benefit plan but not if that state law “regulates insurance” ERISA 514(a)-(b), 29 U.S.C. 1144(a)-(b).

Here, NYS GOL 5-335 absolutely relates to ERISA plans but it is saved from any express and complete preemption because it “regulates insurance”.  A State law that “regulates insurance” is saved from express preemption if it fits the definition of “regulates insurance”.  Regulate insurance is defined as (1) is it “specifically directed toward entities engaged in insurance” and (2) “substantially affect(s) the risk pooling arrangement between insurer and insured.”

In Wurtz,  Plaintiffs were not seeking to enforce or clarify their rights under the terms of their ERISA plan but were using a State Law, GOL 5-335, that regulates insurance to be free from subrogation.  In addition, their state claim was not so intertwined with the interpretation of their ERISA plans.  Instead, an independent duty arose from GOL 5-335 which prohibits insurers from seeking subrogation or reimbursement from settling parties.  The duty is independent because it is unrelated to whatever the ERISA plan states about reimbursement.

It must be noted however that this decision is in conflict with other holdings in the Third, Fourth and Fifth Circuits in similar anti-subrogation matters.  How a law firm is going to use NYS GOL Anti-Subrogation laws against lien demands will be something lawyers will need to continue to  monitor.…but for now lawyers in New York can tell collection companies to “Go Take a Hike!!!”

Related Posts

  • How to preserve your clients’ medical coverage while settling a case
  • Caveat Counsel
  • The Right Approach to Medicare Set Asides
  • ABLE Accounts: providing a better life experience for New York’s disabled residents
  • The CMS Recovery Portal: helping put money in your pocket faster

Filed Under: ERISA Tagged With: Erisa, Medicaid, Medicare, Wurtz v The Rawlings Company

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • ABLE Accounts: providing a better life experience for New York’s disabled residents
  • Bringing Your Client to Mediation: the pros and cons considered
  • How To Identify Which Cases Are Ripe For Mediation
  • The CMS Recovery Portal: helping put money in your pocket faster
  • Getting the Most of Out of Your Next Mediation

Search

Tag Cloud

ABLE ACT 2014 Affordable Care Act Amos v Rodman annuity chronic condition confidentiality clause Dennis Rodman Erisa financial planning Health care insurance adjustors IRS law lien resolution Life Care Plan Life Insurance Benefits litigation mediation mediations mediator Medicaid Medical Law Medicare Medicare Liens Medicare Secondary Payer Act Medicare Set Aside medicare set asides MSA MSP notice of hardship conversion Obama Care personal injury law plaintiff plaintiffs private letter ruling settlements Special Needs Trust structured settlements tax free tax free annuity tax free income tax on settlements trial-ready Wrongful Death Wurtz v The Rawlings Company

Our Mission

As a settlement consulting company owned and run by practicing trial attorneys, ESS brings you true plaintiff-based settlement consultants that are dedicated to serving the plaintiff’s bar and remaining on the cutting edge of settlement planning.

Follow Us Online

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter

Our latest posts

  • ABLE Accounts: providing a better life experience for New York’s disabled residents
  • Bringing Your Client to Mediation: the pros and cons considered
  • How To Identify Which Cases Are Ripe For Mediation
  • The CMS Recovery Portal: helping put money in your pocket faster
  • Getting the Most of Out of Your Next Mediation

Connect With Us

ESS Settlement Services

P: 844-ESS-1212
F: 866-977-1201
E: info@esqsettlements.com
©2015 ESS Settlements Services, LLC - All Rights Reserved

Structured Settlements provided by Sage Settlement Consulting